Log in
Sign up
View all  |  Close all
#
Subject
Posted by
Actions
1
Ancestry.com - is it a better option for research
member
- Close

I ponder (often) if it might be a more productive and far less frustratiing option to cut my losses and move entirley to Ancestry.com.

Unfortunatley I made the mistake of buying a 2 year premuim Plus subscription to myheritage, I really think I should have dome moe homework.

Having been disallusioned by myheritage I am concerned that joining Ancestry.com might have me going round in circles in just another USA focused arena. With respect to our USA fellow genealogists - there is a bias toward USA and its huge polulation- but often to the expense of the rest of the entire planet!!.

So my question really is- should I jump ship now or wait oiu until my subscription ends and then see what is in the market place then.

- Reply
2
RE: desire for Australian content.
Roslyn Seare
- Close

I too have purchased the premium plan for 2 years...... I am having very little success with gaining any info at all for Australia.

Any help please!!!!

Roslyn Seare
Australia
- Reply
3
RE: Ancestry.com - is it a better option for research
Charles Herndon
- Close

The truth is that genology is a frustrating and complicated endeavor, no matter which venue you use to try and produce a good family tree.  You should never take anyone's word as a fact without verifiable, source based proof.  Otherwise, you're just asking for problems and erroneous information.  I learned this the hard way, just as you seem to have done.  All of the companies out there have their own little quirks and it really doesn't matter which one you use, if you do not use due dilligence in your research, you are goning to have errors in your tree.

As to the lady who replied to you, I have a bit of a problem with someone who claims they are happy to share their research results with others, but who is so concerned about privacy.  If her information is so good, why would she be concerned about who may look at the information, and then, I hope, do their own research to validate the information before adding  it to their tree.  She sounds a little like a politician who say they have one viewpoint, then does everything in their power to reflect exactly the opposite viewpoint in their actions.  Charles.

Charles Herndon
Austin, TX
- Reply
4
RE: Ancestry.com - is it a better option for research
Rhianna W
- Close

I understand your issue with US-centric records databases. It's completely valid that you want to see more Australian records available.

I hope you'll understand that the genealogy market is what drives the result you see. Genealogy is far more popular in the US than anywhere else in the world. Any business trying to survive would be foolish to ignore that fact.

However, we are doing our best to change things. It's not in vain that MyHeritage is translated to 37 languages (and counting). We really are trying to bring about a more global approach to family history research. 

Now that we've acquired World Vital Records, we're going to increase and widen the range of information available there. 

It takes time though. And patience. 

 

Rhianna W
Tel Aviv, Israel
- Reply
5
RE: Ancestry.com - is it a better option for research
Deleted member
- Close
If you go to Ancestry be sure to mark your tree private or you will find all your hard work all over the other trees and many of them are just name collectors. If your tree is private someone who has a match with you contacts you through Ancestry's message system and then you can decide how much to share with them. It's not a bad system.

If you want a site where you can upload your tree to display for yourself and others, and is not too expensive, try Tribal Pages, www.tribalpages.com. They have various privacy levels for you to choose from, have a method for others to contact you if they find a match and have a very good looking and well organized presentation of your tree. Very easy to use. This has been my favourite site for years.

From a research perspective especially if you are not from the USA and only want to research in the UK, for example, then buy a subscription to ancestry.co.uk only. If you wish to research in Canada then ancestry.ca or buy a world membership and research in the UK, Canada and the US.

If you want UK research Find My Past is a favourite of mine. 

And don't forgetthe free Family Search sie, they have loads of different data bases.

Hope this has been helpful and I also hope I don't start regretting buying this premium membership although I have already detected some issues.

 

Deleted member
- Reply
6
RE: Ancestry.com - is it a better option for research [2]
member
- Close
I can honestly not say whether I am sad or offended ...

My hours of hard work in the name of genealogy is an open and FREE candystore to whomever could/would have good use of my findings regarding to my (and their) line of ancestors - I get very sad to hear that some think that knowledge of our ancestors is privat just because we have found it.

Namecollecters or not - what is the problem - just let them - if they think that is i fun having 1.857 names to show in their line ...

Namecollectors have helped me finding relatives because they had copied some "namelists" with some names "sticking out" that i haven't found be my self.

 Well, just me opinion ...

- Reply
7
RE: Ancestry.com - is it a better option for research [2]
Eric Dalton
- Close
My problem, and I expect that of many others, is that I took that shaking green leaf way too seriously and copied every thing I found there without thinking about it. I was impressed to find how far my direct line went. Later I learned that a lot of those "ancestors" are mythological beings. Took me until I transferred my tree here to figure it all out and then fix it. I had a lot of stuff to clean up, and out. I think I still see a lot of those which either directly or indirectly got their trees from ancestry.
Eric Dalton
- Reply
8
RE: Ancestry.com - is it a better option for research [3]
Deleted member
- Close

Yes, Ancestry members can be bad for incorrect information which is duplicated over and over. Examples are children being born in different centuries (how on earth would you not notice this), multiple husbands and wives with children all being born at the same time (doesn't take much to go figure them all out), census records for deceased parents (and these even have different children so seriously people)....I could go on ad infinitum.

However, occassionally you can find that long lost relative or one you didn't know about. Take the name and then do your own research. Never click on the shaking leaf, lol. 

It's still a good site for research and as long as you take the information in the trees with a grain of salt you're okay.

Deleted member
- Reply
 
Loading...
Loading...